The Központi Statisztikai Hivatal (KSH) has pushed back against criticism of the database behind its income-based poverty indicator, saying the data is reliable and that no multiplier factors were applied during a revision.
Researcher disputes reliability
Researcher Tátrai Annamária said the KSH had acknowledged only minor errors and argued these do not affect the value of the poverty rate. “In our view, however, the entire database is unreliable,” she said.
Researchers had pointed to several anomalies in the data, including a sharp drop in the share of family allowance recipients in 2022, a divergence between entrepreneurial income recipients and operating businesses, and uniform fixed-rate changes in some incomes after revision. They noted that unemployment benefit for all recipients in the database rose by 30.7 percent compared with the pre-revision state, and identified a uniform discrepancy of 1.307306 tied to the correction of gross-up calculations for unemployment benefits. For 2021, they found 14 percent of employees saw income fall by a uniform 14.2 percent after revision, while another 14 percent saw a 25 percent decline.
KSH explains the gaps
The KSH said the revision did not involve retroactively modifying previously published final data files, but rather a renewed processing of raw data under an updated methodology. It said the decline in the share of family allowance recipients is explained by a higher data gap for that year.
In 2022, respondents reported family allowance at a much lower rate than usual, the KSH said, and it did not fill the missing data with estimates during the revision. The agency said it did not apply multiplier factors, and that the recurring multipliers identified by researchers may have arisen from successive steps in processing income data. The KSH said it is examining the possibility of a further data revision for family allowance.
Source: KSH








